Dr. David Clark, DC -Center for Low Thyroid Solutions in Durham, NC-helps women suffering with low thyroid symptoms avoid the huge mistake of taking tyrosine supplements.
Huge Mistake #2 Made by Women Suffering with Low Thyroid
A long time ago someone mis-interpreted some research and they concluded that tyrosine would be good for thyroid metabolism.
There’s never been a single study to show that tyrosine improves thyroid hormone metabolism.
In fact, what really happens is tyrosine gets converted into catecholamines such as epinephrine and norepinephrine and these compounds actually suppress thyroid function and worsen her symtpoms. You can look it up.
This shines a real bright light on something I was just talking about on another post..
The problem is that this realm of “alternative” medicine, in a lot of ways is not so alternative.
They have their conventional standard way of doing things that have been going on for 30 or 40 years and they’re doing it blindly…. and they’re doing it without even referencing or thinking about new scientific findings.
Tyrosine in fact doesn’t do anything good for improving thyroid metabolism.
What it does more often than not is actually suppress thyroid metabolism by converting into sympathetic nervous system chemicals, adrenaline and noradrenaline, epinephrine and norepinephrine. These will slow down thyroid function.
So here’s a common scenario… a woman starts feeling low thyroid symptoms like
And she seeks help at her local health food store or she goes to the mall, or she even sees a well-meaning alternative medicine practitioner. And that person, since they don’t understand the full spectrum of what can be causing low thyroid, suggests tyrosine–which will probably only make her symptoms worse.
Side note: Often the NON-effectiveness of tyrosine gets missed because the woman will take the tyrosine as part of a supplement with MANY ingredients, some that might actually help. So it’s a two steps forward, three steps back situation.
But because it’s kind of a tradition, the well-meaning health food store or practitioner looks in one of these books that you can get for $10 or $15. It’s like a recipe book for all sorts of ‘common” problems. (You know what I’m talking about.)
They flip it open; say oh, the person needs tyrosine and iodine. Iodine I already talked about, and they give the woman tyrosine and what usually happens is…nothing happens. Or they give her tyrosine and because tyrosine is converted into chemicals that will further squash her pituitary and thyroid…she feels worse. Yuck!
So the second mistake I see, the first one was iodine and please go back and look at that post. The second mistake is tyrosine support.
Tyrosine support should not be used with someone with low thyroid.
It just shouldn’t. There are formulas available that do not contain tyrosine–But better yet, don’t even try to supplement yourself. Find someone that understands the complex nature of thyroid hormones. And it is more complicated than iodine and tyrosine.
The thing you’ve gotta remember and I’m gonna say this a million times if you listen to me very often…
The number one cause of low thyroid in America is an autoimmune disease called Hashimoto’s.
If you have Hashimoto’s autoimmune thyroiditis, it needs to be controlled right now.
Because if you don’t get it under control, that autoimmune process is going to march through your body and find other things to kill…such as your pancreas, brain, cartilage. I think understand how these could ruin your life.
So it’s time to do your homework. If you’ve got low thyroid problems, please, don’t take tyrosine. Find a doctor that can actually do the detective work and find out what’s wrong.
© 2010 Dr. David Clark, DC DACNB DCCN FACFN FABVR
Dr. David Clark,DC -Center for Low Thyroid Solutions in Durham, NC-blows the lid off the biggest mistake women with low thyroid can make….taking iodine.
The Biggest Mistake A Woman With Low Thyroid Can Make is Taking Iodine.
Make sure you understand what I’m saying…
Iodine should not be used in someone who’s suffering with low thyroid symptoms.
I know that flies right in the face of a few very prominent “thyroid experts,” but here’s what you don’t know about iodine.
You’ve probably been told that iodine is necessary for thyroid hormone synthesis. And it is, but here is the problem…taking supplemental iodine is dangerous and here’s why.
Over the last 20 years, in various places around the world with iodine depleted soil, well-meaning groups have gone in and tried to cure the goiters. A goiter develops when you get a swelling of the thyroid gland because you’re iodine deficient.
See, that’s where it starts. This thinking that well, if you’re iodine deficient, give people iodine to get rid of their goiter—that must be good for someone who has low thyroid.– Hang with me for a second.
How’d you like to be one of those people? You can clap yourself on the back. Hey, we cured your goiter but we also gave you Hashimoto’s autoimmune thyroiditis.
What that means is iodine is a trigger. It’s a trigger for Hashimoto’s autoimmune thyroid.
Hashimoto’s autoimmune thyroid is the number one cause of low thyroid in America–not iodine deficiency.
This whole issue of iodine exposes a nasty similarity between traditional medicine and “alternative” medicine.
Traditional medicine is looking at TSH and T4 and T3 and they didn’t really care about iodine. They’re not even going to give you iodine because whatever the real cause of your low thyroid symptoms might be..the only thing you’re going to get from them is replacement thyroid hormones. No matter what. It’s pretty much the only tool they have to offer. (And you know the old saying…”If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like nails.”)
They don’t care if the cause of your symptoms is
—doesn’t matter. You’re getting thyroid hormones from the traditional medical doctor. This is why so many women STILL feel terrible.
So traditional medicine has nice little box. You’ve heard of thinking “outside the box?” Well Traditional medicine has their nice little dusty box, been sittingt here for 30, 40 years and that’s how they do it. (humph!)
Over here we have the not so alternative-alternative medicine approach. And what they do is they also have their sad, outdated box way of thinking. Inside their box is the idea that everyone with low thyroid needs iodine supplementation, or tyrosine, or broad immune system support ,or they need to take thyroid glandulars.
Here’s what the not-so-alternative medicine doesn’t know…conventional medicine, they do some testing. Not-so-alternative medicine does almost no testing at all. They’re still doing things like the Barnes underarm thyroid test and that is an ancient, prehistoric, non-useful way of evaluating the thyroid.
There are also people in this camp that are doing the iodine absorption test as if that had any real relationship to your need for iodine (it doesn’t).
The craziest thing is that these not-so-alternative practitioners ignore the fact that iodine is a trigger for Hashimoto’s. If you wanna give yourself Hashimoto’s, keep taking the iodine that one of the not-so-alternative medicine doctors gave you. They mean well, by the way. I’m not trying to slam them.
But that well meaning “alternative” doctor doesn’t understand the fact that what we’re really dealing with, almost 90 percent of the time, is not low iodine.The problem is an autoimmune problem.
And you can look through my other posts on Hashimoto’s; it’s a very complex issue. But iHashimoto’s can be managed and you can feel great again.
A WARNING YOU MUST READ…
If you think you’ve got low thyroid….please don’t go to the health food store and open the book “Prescription for nutritional healing” or ask the minimum wage employee what to do, because you’re going to get recommended iodine (or you’re gonna get tyrosine, I’ll talk about tyrosine later. )
Iodine is a trigger. One of the studies I quoted calls it an “explosive mix.”
That’s what I want you to remember. If you’re taking iodine—and you’ve got low thyroid symptoms—and you haven’t had the correct tests done—you don’t even know if you’re autoimmune or not–taking Iodine is like swallowing a burning stick of dynamite with a long fuse on it.
It could trigger a massive autoimmune process that can’t be stopped.(but could be slowed down)
See, having low thyroid symptoms because of an “underactive” thyroid gland is one thing, although not as common as you might think.
Having an autoimmune disease is a whole ‘nother ball game and if you keep taking iodine, you are playing Russian roulette with six loaded barrels. You’re swallowing dynamite.
I don’t know how many analogies I can mix here but you need to stop.
That’s the biggest thyroid mistake I see. A person with low thyroid symptoms taking iodine.
Iodine is a trigger for autoimmune Hashimoto’s thyroiditis.
© 2010 Dr. David Clark